All roads lead to Jerusalem

It's only fair to share...Share on Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Email this to someone

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni's failure to form a government proved that all roads do in fact lead to Jerusalem. It was the issue of Jerusalem that deadlocked and ultimately scuttled Livni's coalition negotiations with Shas, which demanded that she pledge not to negotiate the partition of the city with the Palestinians. Livni refused to make such a pledge. And so the negotiations failed and new elections will soon be called.

In refusing to agree to Shas's demand, Livni made clear that partitioning the city – that is, giving the Palestinians sovereignty over the Temple Mount and the Arab neighborhoods – is so central to her preferred foreign policy that she could not budge on the issue despite her obvious desire to take up residence in the Prime Minister's Office. Moreover, it showed that she believes that the bulk of her potential voters hail from the post-Zionist Left. To win their support, she had to make clear that she is one of them.

In making Jerusalem, rather than welfare payments the wedge issue in their negotiations with Livni, Shas's leaders demonstrated their recognition of the fact that defending Israeli sovereignty over the capital city is more important to their voters than increasing welfare. Had they entered a Livni government without securing a pledge to defend Jerusalem, Shas would have been hard pressed to compete with the Likud in the coming elections.

Due to the centrality of Jerusalem in Livni's failed negotiations with Shas, it is apparent that maintaining or ending sovereignty over united Jerusalem will be the central issue of the coming elections. If the Left can convince a sufficient number of voters that a united Jerusalem is a drain on the country's resources or that it is impossible to enforce Israeli law among an increasingly lawless and irredentist Arab population, then it will have a fighting chance of winning the elections.

If the Right is able to demonstrate that the problems that afflict Jerusalem are little different from those suffered by mixed Jewish-Arab cities throughout the country and are a consequence of government and municipal mismanagement and are therefore manageable, then it will win the elections.

TODAY THE problems that Jerusalem faces stem from its unique demographic character, municipal mismanagement and the clear if previously unstated intention of successive leftist governments to eventually withdraw from the Temple Mount and from the city's Arab neighborhoods.

Jerusalem's ranking today as the poorest city in the country redounds to the fact that that the majority of its residents are Arab and haredi. These two sectors by and large do not work and do not pay municipal taxes. As a consequence, the municipal tax burden falls on the plurality of Jerusalemites who work and pay taxes – mainly religious Zionists and non-observant Jews. Due to the unfair tax burden, recent years have seen a steady stream of the city's productive residents migrating to surrounding communities where the tax burden is more evenly distributed and municipal services are consequently better.

Beyond the chronic problem of under-collection of taxes, Jerusalem suffers from problems of lawlessness among its Arab residents not unlike the problems that affect all cities with mixed Jewish and Arab populations. This Arab lawlessness is facilitated on a national level by the government's refusal to order the police and the State Attorney's Office to enforce and apply the law equally to Arab citizens.

Jerusalem also suffers from unique problems with lawlessness and underdevelopment. These problems have been created by successive governments that have silently encouraged the partition of the city by both enabling the PA to field militiamen in the city's Arab neighborhoods and discouraging and indeed prohibiting Jewish building in areas the government foresees being transferred to Palestinian sovereignty. These manufactured problems have retarded development and expansion plans. They have also artificially raised housing prices for the city's Jewish residents.

One of the chief responsibilities of Palestinian militia that operate in the city has been to enforce the PA's anti-Semitic law which defines the sale of land to Jews as a capital offense. Since 1994, dozens of Arab Jerusalemites have been executed by these men and their Fatah masters in Ramallah and Jericho for the "crime" of selling land to Jews. The government has made little effort to prosecute the offenders. Since 2004, when prime minister Ariel Sharon forced internal security minister Uzi Landau to resign due to Landau's opposition to Sharon's sharp turn to the left, the police have not been ordered to rein in the activities of the militia.

Largely as a consequence of this state of affairs, Jews are prevented from living in half of the city. The scarcity of housing options for Jews is what has caused an artificial increase in housing prices that has compelled young families to migrate out of the city.

Another factor contributing to the scarcity of land for Jewish building is the government's refusal to permit the building of new neighborhoods in areas like E-1 near Mount Scopus. Commerce is stifled, among other reasons, because the government has refrained from ordering the IDF to reassert control over Atarot municipal airport and industrial zone after the Palestinians began murdering businessmen, shooting passing motorists and threatening air traffic in 2000. In essence, as the building of the separation fence within Jerusalem's municipal boundaries shows clearly, the government has been effectively enacting the partition of the city for the past several years without ever acknowledging this fact.

The government's effective support for partition is perhaps nowhere more obvious than on the Temple Mount. There, the Islamic Wakf not only incites for jihad with impunity, it is also systematically destroying the remains of the Second Temple with impunity. The abject abandonment of Judaism's holiest site by successive governments has facilitated not only the radicalization of Jerusalem Arabs from surrounding neighborhoods, like Silwan, it has also emboldened global jihadists to believe that Jerusalem – and Israel with it – will soon fall into their hands.

IN LIGHT of these difficult realities, it is a relief that Jerusalemites are likely to elect Nir Barkat as their new mayor on November 11. While the mayor of Jerusalem has only a limited capacity to solve the unique, politically-driven maladies endangering the city, he does have considerable power to solve the problems that are similar to those impacting other cities nationwide. He can compel residents to pay their municipal taxes. He can enforce building codes. And he can use his power and influence to facilitate new building while improving municipal infrastructure to encourage economic growth and population expansion.

Barkat is a 48-year-old Jerusalemite. He served as a company commander in the paratroopers, and then went on to make a fortune in the hi-tech sector. In 1999, he and his wife became active philanthropists supporting various Zionist educational causes related to the city. In 2003 he retired from his business ventures to run for mayor. His party, Yerushalayim Tatzliah (Jerusalem will succeed), won 43 percent of the vote. Barkat has served for five years as the head of the opposition in the city council. In 2005, he joined Kadima.

Last year, he broke with Kadima when he discovered that the government was conducting negotiations on the partition of Jerusalem with Fatah leaders. Emerging as a staunch defender of the city's unity, he was one of the prominent leaders of the national opposition movement which arose to demand that the government end its negotiations on the issue.

As a mayoral candidate, Barkat has assembled a candidates list for his party comprised of members of the Likud, the
Gil Pensioners Party, the Green Party and Labor. They have committed themselves to a common platform pledged to defend and facilitate continued Israeli sovereignty over the entire city.

In a recent conversation, Barkat explained to me that enforcing law and order in the Arab neighborhoods while encouraging local, non-jihadist neighborhood councils to take a leadership role in their communities is one of his primary goals.

"Today we have a crazy situation in which the number of municipal inspectors assigned to a neighborhood is inversely proportional to the degree of building code violations. We have four times more municipal inspectors assigned to Jewish neighborhoods than to Arab neighborhoods which have four times more building violations. I will reverse this situation as mayor."

Barkat also intends to push hard to build a new neighborhood for young people in E-1. To date, building in E-1 has been blocked by the government which as bowed to US pressure not to build in the strategically critical area that connects Jerusalem to Ma'aleh Adumim.

Barkat also intends to encourage economic growth in the city by developing its tourist sector. He correctly identifies projects like the City of David as sites with massive tourist potential. He believes that the proper way to achieve his goal of bringing 10 million tourists a year is to develop tourist attractions that link the Old City to surrounding areas like Gush Etzion.

Barkat has a vision of setting up a council of metropolitan Jerusalem that will involve the heads of the Jewish communities around the city in its overall development plans. This he believes will encourage business growth and lead to more rational long-term urban planning and infrastructure development.

Barkat's headquarters bustle with campaign workers. Most of them are in their early 20s. They hail from both non-observant and national religious backgrounds. Their enthusiasm for his candidacy is a product of his chairmanship of the non-profit Ruah Hadasha (new spirit) organization that helps students find post-university job opportunities in Jerusalem and encourages student involvement in the city. Yakir Segev, who founded and directs Ruah Hadasha, is one of the senior members of Barkat's party.

There is no guarantee, of course, that Barkat will be able to succeed in contending with the daunting challenges facing the city. But there is no doubt that if elected, he will bring a new integrity and commitment to the office and a welcome vision for Jerusalem that is both attractive and eminently achievable. Indeed, it is the success of Barkat's vision that will put paid the notion that united Jerusalem is ungovernable.

If as the polls indicate, Barkat wins the mayoral race in two weeks, the overwhelming majority of Israelis who are committed to safeguarding Israeli sovereignty over the eternal capital of the Jewish people will find a formidable ally in city hall.

Originally published in The Jerusalem Post.

It's only fair to share...Share on Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Email this to someone


  • Marc Handelsman, USA 10/28/2008 at 0:55

    Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni’s inability to unite a ruling coalition is proof of her weak leadership. It is possible that the foreign minister might be the last leader of Kadima. As long as Kadima rules, Israeli sovereignty over Jerusalem is imperiled. The country knows the Kadima experiment failed. Hopefully, Nir Barkat will be Jerusalem’s next mayor. Parts of Jerusalem are ungovernable, and the rule of law needs to be reestablished. It’s time for Israel to give Likud an opportunity to govern again. And America needs to move its embassy to Jerusalem.

  • Scott 10/28/2008 at 6:34

    Perhaps,Ms.Glick…Mrs.Livni may be trying to break the cycle of extortion and corruption that has polluted Israel for so many years…I hope so

  • JIM 10/28/2008 at 7:35

    What about Nenteyahu running? Well my Israeli friends, it’s about time a politician had rejected
    the division of Jerusalem. Now, I’ve been to Israel and did visit Jerusalem-such a beutiful city. I always feared that some jack booted politician seeking fame and fortune would play
    poker against Jerusalem-winner takes all.
    Your last PM was just about to play poker using
    Jerusalem as collaterol, but thank God he had to
    resign. Now comes Livini, who wants to make a name for herself by forcing the Jerusalem status
    as a playing chip.
    Again, I thank God that the Shas has voted against her now a new elections must be had.
    I don’t understand why Prez Bush does not move the US embassy (as he promised) to Jerusalem so
    that all the world can bare witness that the US
    recognizes that Jerusalem is the true holy capitol of Israel. But chicken shit always get in the way.
    My friends, don’t give not one inch of land away
    to the Arabs for biblically speaking, the whole
    West Bank was for thousands of years part of Israel.
    It is time that politicians pay no mind to the
    American president or congress.
    We in the US if being force to give back land to
    Mexico would ourselves tell the world to go to hell. So I say this…what’s good for the geese,
    is good for the gander. For if you ,the Jewish
    people, fight for what gave you, God will bless
    you and strength you.
    Observe the fail policy changes of Sec Rice where Hamas took control of Gaza and confiscated
    all the ammo, m16s,trucks, humvees, radios, and
    the list goes on. Now Hamas is using it against
    Israeli….nice foreign policy courtesy of Rice.
    I admire Sec Rice but when she’s in the face of Israelis pushing for land give away etc cause
    Prez Bush wants a “positive” legacy of accomplish…tell her to take Bush’s planned legacy elsewhere. No land No Jerusalem not now,
    not later , and not ever.

  • Scott 10/28/2008 at 8:29

    I have waited for hours…

  • Timothy Kriete For Israel Forever More AMEN 10/28/2008 at 9:16

    Dear Caroline;
    Hey Sis, AMEN On This Article And Thank YOU For
    Your BOLDNESS And Courage To Declare The TRUTH
    In The Agape’ Love Of Jehovah EL Shaddai AMEN.
    “Jerusalem, Where EMPIRES DIE, Will America Die
    At Jerusalem???” Prophetic Book Witten And
    Published In 1984 By Dr. Lester Frank Sumrall
    Gospel Globe Trotter FOR ZION’S SAKE AMEN :):):)
    “I Love You ALL And You Can’t Do Anything About
    It” Quote From 1 Of The Local Pastors Joy L.
    Thornton AMEN. Genesis 12:1-3,Isaiah 62 AMEN.
    (Esther 4:14, Joel 2:21-32, Isaiah 62 AMEN).
    Thy Servant And Brother FOR ZION’S SAKE Timothy
    Kriete (Romans 12:1-3, Isaiah 53, Psalm 23 AMEN)

  • marcel cousineau 10/28/2008 at 14:17

    The world’s plan to make Jerusalem a capitol of their newly formed Islamic state is impossible and unworkable if peace is the true goal.
    The moslems will not be satisfied until they have reclaimed all of Israel.
    For Jews to ignore this fact and appease this unrelenting enemy with gifts of Jewish land only fuels the jihad.This is why the arab population has become more lawless,they see the defeatist, fearful, grasshopper’s of Israel in retreat and surrender on every front.
    Barkat finds himself fighting most of Israel and the world to keep Jerusalem united. How easily the political leadership of Israel capitulated to the nightmare vision Road Map without a fight. How is it that defeatists like Livni,Barak,Mofaz,Olmert are in such high places of power in Israel ?
    This peace at all cost insanity of Israel’s political parties has already done great damage and more is on the way.
    The left has done enough damage to Israel ,it’s time to remove them before they do more damage.A military coup would be good for Israel and save the nation from the traitors in power who only serve a declining superpower and it’s failed peace plan..
    The greatest danger Israel faces is between now and the elections.
    This will give Olmert more time to accomplish the Palestinian state dream of his master,President Bush, before they end their diabolical reign of rewarding Palestinian terrorism and oppressing the faithful Jews of Israel.
    Watch for Olmert to begin the ethnic cleansing of Jews from Judea and Samaria between now and election’s in Feburary so this president can have his nobel peace prize to offset his failed 8 years or ruin and disaster.
    Israel is the sacrifical lamb for this blind ambition.

  • Ron Grandinetti 10/28/2008 at 15:58

    I still find it difficult to understand the whole Jerusalem problem. Why should any authority other than the Jews have control of any portion of Israel, including the Gaza strip.
    Only a united Israel under Jewish control will ultimately lead to peace. Cutting up the territory will not solve the problem, but add to the problem.
    Israel, stand tall the country is yours to safeguard and protect all the inhabitants including law abiding Arab citizens.

  • Scott 10/29/2008 at 6:41

    The day that Israel slaps a machine gun down into every parasite Orthodox hand is the day that Israel will be free…who are the real Jews?

  • Scott 10/29/2008 at 7:02

    Give Tzipi Livni a chance…if she fails then so what…Israel is most corrupt democracy on earth!Yes,Kadima,Likud,Labour,Shas….the Knesset is a sewer…if you don’t like this,then don’t print it,Ms. Glick

  • dean 11/02/2008 at 21:17

    The problem Jerusalem faces is 100%spiiritual and always has benn. The devil wants what belongs to God. And n ow the battle sides are being formed. What is about to happen will be no less than a shaking of the entire earth as foretold in the bible. Read Zechariah 12 vs. 2.


Leave a Comment