What the Palestinians buy with American money

It's only fair to share...Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someoneShare on Google+
fayyad burning goods.jpg
Two weeks ago, a Palestinian from Bethlehem was arrested by the US-financed and trained Palestinian Authority security forces. He was charged with “carrying out commercial transactions with residents of a hostile state.”

 

No, he was not buying uranium from Iran. His purported crime was purchasing wood products from an Israeli community located beyond the 1949 armistice lines.

 

Denied bail by the US-funded PA magistrate’s court in Bethlehem, he has been remanded to custody pending the conclusion of his trial.

 

This man’s arrest is part of what the unelected, US-supported Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad has touted as his “National Honor Fund.” The goal of this project is to ban all economic contact between Palestinians and Jews who live and work beyond the 1949 armistice lines. As far as the supposedly moderate Fayyad is concerned, those Jews and Israel generally comprise the “hostile state,” that the Palestinians under Fayyad’s leadership are being compelled to boycott.

 

Speaking to The Jerusalem Post, Palestinian Labor Minister Ahmed Majdalani said the PA hopes that by the end of the year all the thousands of Palestinians who are employed in Israeli communities in Judea and Samaria will quit their jobs. What he didn’t mention is that if they don’t quit, they will be arrested.

 

According to PA Economics Minister Hassan Abu Libdeh, since the start of Fayyad’s campaign, the PA has confiscated $1 million worth of Israeli products including foods, cosmetics and hardware from Palestinian stores.

 

Fayyad’s measures come on top of previously enacted PA measures like imposing the death penalty on Palestinians who sell land to Jews. Less than two months ago, the PA reaffirmed that it will continue to execute any Palestinian who commits this “crime.”

 

There is no way to credibly claim that these actions advance either the cause of peaceful coexistence or Palestinian economic prosperity. Yet it is precisely in the hope of advancing these goals that the US government funds the PA.

 

DESPITE HIS campaign to boycott Israel and punish Palestinians with economic ties to the Jewish state, Fayyad is the US’s favorite Palestinian. Since PA President Mahmoud Abbas appointed Fayyad to lead the rump Fatah government in Judea and Samaria after Hamas took over the Gaza Strip, US aid to the PA has increased by more than 700 percent. Most of this aid has gone to propping up Fayyad.

 

The US directly finances his budget. It funds and trains a Palestinian military. And it subsidizes his programs to build governmental institutions that loyally carry out his anti-Israel policies.

 

Last Wednesday, during a joint press conference with Fayyad, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton announced the US will give the PA an additional $150 million in aid to supplement the $400 million in financial assistance that President Barack Obama pledged in June. This supplement comes in response to Fayyad’s claim that he needs $500 million to close his budget shortfall.

 

According to the Congressional Research Service, the PA is the largest recipient of foreign assistance in the world. According to Bloomberg, it received $1.2 billion in 2009 and will receive $1.8 billion by the end of the year.

 

The US provided the PA with $500.9 million in 2009 and, before Clinton’s announcement, was scheduled to provide it with $550 million in 2011. This assistance does not include US financial support for UNRWA, an agency devoted exclusively to providing welfare benefits to Palestinians while subordinating itself to a Palestinian political agenda. The US is the single largest donor to UNRWA. Last year the $268 million US taxpayers gave the UN agency constituted 27 percent of UNRWA’s budget.

 

Congresswoman Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, who is expected to become the chairwoman of the House Foreign Relations Committee in the next Congress, responded negatively to Clinton’s announced expansion of US aid to the PA. In a statement released by her office last Thursday, Ros-Lehtinen derided the assistance as a “bailout.”

 

She further commented, “It is deeply disturbing that the administration is continuing to bail out the Palestinian leadership when they continue to fail to meet their commitments, under international agreements and requirements outlined in US law, including dismantling the Palestinian terrorist infrastructure, combating corruption, stopping anti-Israel and anti-Semitic incitement and recognizing Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state.”

 

Ros-Lehtinen authored the Palestinian Anti-Terrorism Act of 2006, which conditioned US assistance to the PA on, among other things, “publicly acknowledge[ing] the Jewish state of Israel’s right to exist.”

 

While on the mark, Ros-Lehtinen’s statement only scratches the surface of how contrary to US law and the goals of Palestinian economic development and peace US financial assistance to the Palestinians truly is.

 

Take US security assistance to the Palestinians. The US responded to the Hamas takeover in Gaza by massively increasing its military assistance to Fatah. According to the CRS, between 2007 and August 2010, US assistance to the PA security services totaled $400 million. They received $100 million in 2010 and are set to receive $150 million in 2011. This assistance has paid for the training and outfitting of 400 Presidential Guards and 2,700 soldiers in the National Security Forces. The US plans to train five additional 500-man NSF battalions.

 

The CRS report acknowledged these forces have improved the law and order situation in Judea and Samaria. But it also asserted that “uncertainty remains over the durability of these improvements and their connection with broader Palestinian economic and civil society development and with progress on Israeli-Palestinian negotiations as well as over the willingness and ability of the forces to incapacitate militants.”

 

Indeed, there is little reason to believe that these US-trained forces will not join forces with Hamas and turn their guns on Israel in the future. Since 1996, PA security services have taken a leading role in the terror war against Israel.

 

Concerned about the threat these forces pose, particularly in light of Fayyad’s rejection of Israel’s right to exist, earlier this year OC Central Command Maj.-Gen. Avi Mizrahi warned that these US-trained forces constitute a qualitative jump in the Palestinians’ war fighting capabilities against Israel.

 

As he put it, “This is a well trained force, better equipped than its predecessors and trained by the US. The significance of this is that at the start of a new battle [with the Palestinians] the price that we will pay will be higher. A force like this one can shut down a built-up area with four snipers. This is deadly. These aren’t the fighters we faced in Jenin [in 2002]. This is an infantry force that will be fighting us and we need to take this into account. They have offensive capabilities and we aren’t expecting them to give up.”

 

Then there is the US direct assistance to the PA’s operating budget. The US has provided $350 million in direct budgetary assistance to the PA in the past two years. There are three problems with this aid.

 

First, it is far from clear that the PA needs this assistance. According to the International Monetary Fu
nd and the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics, in 2009 real GDP in Judea and Samaria and the Gaza Strip grew by 6.8 percent, (8.5% in Judea and Samaria). The report also claimed that unemployment declined. So if things are going so well, why is it necessary for foreign donor countries to increase their direct assistance to Fayyad’s budget? 

 

Second, given Fayyad’s rejection of free trade principles, particularly as they relate to Israel, the PA’s largest trading partner, it is hard to see how his economic leadership is credible. As the failed stimulus packages in the US have shown clearly, government bureaucracies do not create jobs. That is the work of the private sector. And yet, Fayyad is barring Palestinians from having trade ties with their most important business partners and commercial market. This is not the behavior of a leader who is interested in facilitating sustainable economic growth.

 

Finally, the simple truth is that it is impossible to prevent US budgetary assistance to the PA from financing Hamas, in contravention of US law. Each month Fayyad transfers funds to Hamas-controlled Gaza to pay the salaries of PA employees there. Fayyad has argued that this assistance cannot be considered material aid to Hamas, since the employees are employed by the PA. But this is nonsense.

 

These employees serve at the pleasure of Hamas. Paying their salaries contravenes US law as well as international law, which prohibits states from providing any assistance whatsoever to areas controlled by terrorists. This is true even if the actual money he transfers to Gaza comes from other income sources. Without the direct US budgetary assistance, he wouldn’t be able to funnel money to Gaza.

 

PROVIDING DIRECT budgetary assistance to Fayyad isn’t the only way the US finances Hamas. It also contributes to Hamas by funding UNRWA. US assistance to UNRWA has doubled in the last four years, largely as a way of avoiding providing direct aid to Hamas. Yet the CRS report notes, “In Gaza, most observers acknowledge that the role of UNRWA in providing basic services (i.e., food, health care, education) takes much of the governing burden off Hamas.”

 

In defending its assistance to UNRWA, the State Department told Congress that the aid “directly contributes to the US strategic interest of meeting the humanitarian needs of the Palestinians, while promoting their self-sufficiency. UNRWA plays a stabilizing role in the Middle East through its assistance programs, serving as an important counterweight to extremists.”

 

But the fact of the matter is that UNRWA employees are Hamas members and sympathizers. And despite the State Department’s claim that it has adopted safeguards to ensure that US assistance is not transferred to individuals and groups with links to Hamas and other terror groups, UNRWA’s checks against terrorism are restricted to checking a UN list of banned terror groups that includes only al-Qaida and the Taliban. As the CRS report noted, UNRWA’s terror screening list “does not include Hamas, Hizbullah or most other militant groups that operate in UNRWA’s surroundings.” In other words, UNRWA continues to employ terrorists, and its current procedures do nothing to prevent that.

 

A Framework of Cooperation agreement signed this year between UNRWA and the US sets out 15 steps for UNRWA to expand its terror screening. But the agreement is nonbinding. Moreover, its provisions in no way block terror-linked individuals or groups from receiving aid from UNRWA.

 

In truth, given the PA’s refusal to recognize Israel’s right to exist or take sustained, decisive action against terrorism, there is really no way for the US to continue funding it without breaking its own laws. But acknowledging this state of affairs would involve admitting that the peace process is a lie and that any Palestinian state that is formed today will be a terrorist state at war with Israel.

 

The incoming Congress might want to consider these basic truths before it approves further aid to Fayyad and his moderate government.

 

Originally published in The Jerusalem Post. 

 

It's only fair to share...Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someoneShare on Google+

8 Comments

  • Marcel 11/15/2010 at 19:18

    U.S. Army Lt.Gen Keith Daytio spent five years training the Palestinian Army to more efficently kill Jews with the blessing of the Israeli government.
    There is no one in Israel capable of standing up and ending this madness.
    The hour is already extremely late.
    No matter what Fatah or Hamas do against Israel they get a pass and millions funneled to them to advance the end agenda which has never been about peace.It’s beyond me how Israeli’s can not see this by now except for major spiritual blindness that drives them to embrace their American destroyers even as the kniife is slowly,steadily twisted in their back.
    How can Israel be this stupid and blind except for a dark spiritual curtain dropped over their mind and soul.
    No matter how good and obedient Israel is to the U.S. the red light always stays red next to the Palestinian’s always green light
    It’s tragic to see Israel so easliy and willingly led to the slaughter by their own hands.

    Reply
  • Anonymous 11/15/2010 at 20:50

    “… US trained …” Writing the terrorists a check is a pretty remote task, but actually training them requires direct contact with US citizens. Who are these citizens? They can’t be stupid. These terrorists hate the US as much as they Israel. US military personel participating in training them must hate the US in the same way.

    Reply
  • Terry, Eilat - Israel 11/16/2010 at 3:03

    You forgot to mention that every Israeli gov’t. since Oslo has in one way or another supported US policies or has similar policies of it’s own. There is no way to defend Israel as long as the Israeli gov’t. itself promotes an independant Palestinian state. This, of course, includes the Netanyahu gov’t.
    In effect, it is Israel itself that has accepted the phoney Arab narrative & undermined our own position. We are actively engaged in our own national suicide.
    I don’t know why I still bother to write comments, pretty much, I have given up any hope that this country will survive. You write insightful & generally accurate analyses of our situation but you seemingly forget that with our political system, there is no chance that anything you advocate will ever be realized.
    You’re very much like a doctor clinically detailing why his patient is terminal.
    Every morning, I look at three English language newspapers: Ynet, JPost, & Arutz 7. I read & sometimes comment on some articles in Ynet. I glance at the headlines at JPost, I don’t bother to read any articles anymore except your column & that of Sarah Honig. I’m so disgusted at where we’re headed & the sheer stupidity of our politicians that I just can’t read about it any more.
    Just look at Netanyahu’s antics re: Obama & bringing the Palestinians into direct negotiations. Could anything be more surrealistic, such theatre of the absurd?
    I keep making the same observation: while an anti-Israel American president is a problem, what is really important is what we are doing here in Israel. And what are we doing?
    Capitulating, just caving in to any demand no matter how unreasonable, how detrimental.
    So, Dr Glick, you just continue to detail the various stages of our terminal illness but my question to you is that when the patient finally dies, will you be writing the obituary as well?

    Reply
  • Tuvia 11/16/2010 at 6:56

    To initiate a discussion about how the US is breaking its own laws (What the Palestinians buy with American money, November 15, 2010), is to start a conversation about a subject that is near and dear to the heart of every red-blooded American—money. This discussion, as Ms Glick focuses it, goes even more directly to an American’s heart, for (to an American) her essay is not about the PA: it’s about how US tax money is spent; and if there is a hot button today in the US, it’s taxes.
    So Ms Glick, if you are correct about how the US breaks its own laws sending money to the PA, then we have a problem: in hard times, when many in the US are concerned that US government spending can destroy America, how are US tax dollars being spent?
    Illegally?
    Excuse me?
    Ms Glick, an American knows money, and right now an American has to be thinking–my government is taking from me the hard-earned dollars I get from work (that is increasingly difficult to find) and it is spending it illegally?
    Ms Glick, don’t you agree that every American who works—and every American who has lost his job or now worries about keeping his job—should know that money that might stay in America to help create jobs or reduce tax burdens is actually leaving America for reasons not only illegal, but un-American (see below) ?
    Sounds to me like something our Republican, and other politically Conservative, friends in America should know about, don’t you think?
    They should be told, shouldn’t they?
    Isn’t this what friends are for?
    So let’s think : how can we help our American friends?
    As a starter, let’s consider that pro-America lobby groups can initiate a long-term effort to hammer home the extent to which this administration, including its State Department, violates existing US law by deliberately allowing US government money to flow directly and indirectly to terrorist organizations. Perhaps such groups can also hammer home how corruption is absolutely wasting this money.
    What US Congressman is going to vote for corruption? In today’s political climate?
    Also, lawyers and legal scholars can be organized to study how legal actions can be brought against both the US government (here and abroad), and against any business that should choose to do business with PA and/or Gaza entities suspected of being corrupt. As occasionally happens, the law sometimes has to be used to smack people in the pocketbook to remind them what is ‘best practice’, right? So why don’t we help? Of course, we should be sensitive not to offend anyone: any legal action should not be brought by Israel, but rather by individuals and organizations; and the further (politically) from Israel these are, the better.
    Also,we can do more with our elected officials in Washington, who right now seem most interested to cancel projects that seem wasteful (and, might we add, illegal as well). For example, wouldn’t we be doing a public service if every member of Congress who has indicated a displeasure with this current administration was not only briefed regularly about illegal international spending (see above), but also consulted as to how the US can be brought back into compliance with its own laws?
    Think about the headlines: “Congress reigns in illegal gov’t spending.”
    Wouldn’t Americans love that?
    Wouldn’t members of Congress love it?
    We don’t have to stop there. A concerted effort can also be made to contact the most important radio and tv personalities who stand in opposition to the current administration, to help them understand how US laws are being broken to send US tax dollars to those who burn the American flag, promote un-American activities, and support Al Quaida.
    Who needs to talk about Israel? Forget about Jews. This is about important stuff—taxes, money, the American flag, supporting foreign corruption, helping AL Quaida –that, taken together, violate our sense of what America stands for, and symbolizes a liberal-crazed administration hell-bent on change that will destroy the American way of life.
    With friends like these, who will need allies?
    Let’s face it: in America, not only are there laws against sending money to terrorist groups, or sending money to entities that support terrorist groups, there are also laws against participating in or colluding with, corruption .These latter laws, in particular, are taken seriously.
    In America, people go to jail for doing these things.
    Perhaps we can ask American talk-show hosts three questions: One—should the US government be allowed to support terrorists and corruption when it puts Americans into jail for doing that; Two—is this how we should be spending tax dollars; and Three—aren’t such actions un-American?

    Reply
  • naomir 11/16/2010 at 8:17

    Caroline, excellent article, but it doesn’t tell us what we should already know especially American Jews. The US government does not like Israel or for that matter Jews. It has never been as evident as it is now, or perhaps we are finally seeing this country for what it really is. A country led by anti-Semites who would like nothing better than to wipe us off the face of the earth. Of course, it is better to give the money to Hamas and then claim ignorance. Hopefully not only the incoming Congress, but influential Jews and other lovers of Israel will act before it is too late.

    Reply
  • Anonymous 11/16/2010 at 8:24

    U.S. Army Lt.Gen Keith Dayton spent five years training the Palestinian Army to more efficently kill Jews with the blessing of the Israeli government.
    No resistance from the quisling Jews at the helm.
    There is no one in Israel capable of standing up and ending this madness.The hour is already extremely late.
    How easily you are seduced.
    No matter what Fatah or Hamas do against Israel they get a pass and millions funneled to them to advance the end agenda which has never been about peace.It’s beyond me how Israeli’s can not see this by now except for major spiritual blindness that drives them to embrace their American destroyers even as the kniife is slowly,steadily twisted in their back.
    Did anyone warn you before that your close relationship to the US would directly lead to the near extinction of Israel ?
    So much for your misplaced faith in your false god and the Barak’s,Livni’s,Olmert’s and Netanyahu’s who piously bow before them.
    No matter how good and obedient Israel is to the U.S. the red light always stays red.next to the Palestinian’s always green light
    It’s tragic to see Israel so easliy and willingly led to the slaughter by their own hands.

    Reply
  • susanc18 11/16/2010 at 10:03

    As I have always said – they scream about the ’67 lines, all the while looking at the ’56 lines, with an eye on the ’48 lines – but they really want the ’21 lines.

    Reply
  • jamesbiga 11/16/2010 at 19:31

    It’s only going to get worse.

    Reply

Leave a Comment